Lowball


19 Yale Terrace, Montclair NJ

Purchased: 6/1/2005
Purchase Price: $762,000
MLS# 2503228
Sold: 6/26/2008
Sale Price: $705,000

19 Woods End Road, West Orange NJ

Purchased: 6/1/2004
Purchase Price: $379,000
MLS# 2493002
Sold: 6/27/2008
Sale Price: $362,500

31 North Road, Chester NJ

Purchased: 7/23/2004
Purchase Price: $425,000
MLS# 2498591
Sold: 6/26/2008
Sale Price: $390,000

2 Lent Street, East Hanover NJ

Purchased: 8/31/2005
Purchase Price: $595,000
MLS# 2504681
Sold: 6/23/2008
Sale Price: $490,000

3 Ryan Court, Montville NJ

Purchased: 9/7/2006
Purchase Price: $1,883,065
MLS# 2465933
Sold:6/27/2008
Sale Price: $1,875,000

2 Spring Brook Court, Randolph NJ

Purchased: 10/25/2005
Purchase Price: $620,000
MLS# 2502058
Sold:6/16/2008
Sale Price: $580,000

568 Herrick Drive, Rockaway NJ

Purchased: 12/22/2005
Purchase Price: $395,000
MLS# 2501924
Sold:6/27/2008
Sale Price: $385,000

1 Shannon Mountain Lane, Washington Twp NJ

Purchased: 7/23/2003
Purchase Price: $625,000
MLS# 2511748
Sold:6/26/2008
Sale Price: $616,500
(Under the 2003 Purchase Price!)

152 Patriot Hill Drive, Basking Ridge NJ

Purchased: 8/22/2007
Purchase Price: $640,000
MLS# 2498959
Sold:6/26/2008
Sale Price: $610,000

5 Crammer Lane, Hillsborough NJ

Purchased: 9/13/2006
Purchase Price: $495,000
MLS# 2515281
Sold:6/27/2008
Sale Price: $490,000

517 Cicilia Place, Scotch Plains NJ

Purchased: 6/15/2006
Purchase Price: $389,000
MLS# 2512061
Sold: 6/27/2008
Sale Price: $287,500

23 Park Ave, Newton NJ

Purchased: 9/12/2005
Purchase Price: $393,750
MLS# 2469605
Sold: 6/27/2008
Sale Price: $382,500

332 Knox Way, Hopatcong NJ

Purchased: 11/21/2006
Purchase Price: $210,000
MLS# 2516427
Sold: 6/26/2008
Sale Price: $175,000

10 Carolina Ave, Newark NJ

Purchased: 8/9/2006
Purchase Price: $195,000
MLS# 2516055
Sold: 6/26/2008
Sale Price: $50,500

95 Blue Hill Ave, Fairlawn NJ

Purchased: 9/15/2005
Purchase Price: $425,000
MLS#: 2811101
Sold: 6/27/2008
Sale Price: $401,000

Welcome to another edition of Lowball!

Lowball! takes a look at home sales from a different perspective. For those new to Lowball!, a lowball offer is when a buyer offers a significantly lower bid than asking in hopes that the seller accepts the offer. We take a list of home sales from the past month and pick out the sales that have the highest percentage difference between original list price and selling price.

To keep the list length reasonable, we’re going to use 15% as the minimum percentage off last list price to be considered a Lowball! Date range was 5/15-6/22, source GSMLS.

Key
MLS - The Listing ID Number
OLP - Original List Price
LP - Last List Price
SP - Sale Price
% off OLP - The difference between the OLP and SP
% off LP - The difference between LP and SP

Caveat Emptor!

MLS# Town OLP LP SP % off OLP % off LP
2445376 Irvington $185,000 $185,000 $115,000 37.8% 37.8%
2399347 Hillside $235,000 $235,000 $150,000 36.2% 36.2%
2496748 East Orange $179,999 $179,999 $120,000 33.3% 33.3%
2393054 Paterson $275,000 $174,900 $120,000 56.4% 31.4%
2489363 West Milford $49,900 $49,900 $35,000 29.9% 29.9%
2408448 Wyckoff $499,900 $399,000 $286,400 42.7% 28.2%
2489049 Vernon $124,900 $124,900 $90,000 27.9% 27.9%
2447807 Denville $424,900 $349,000 $251,500 40.8% 27.9%
2471176 Irvington $186,000 $167,400 $128,000 31.2% 23.5%
2429468 Elizabeth $249,000 $198,000 $152,000 39.0% 23.2%
2428373 Fairfield $339,000 $299,000 $230,000 32.2% 23.1%
2495996 Waldwick $485,500 $485,500 $375,000 22.8% 22.8%
2439337 Millburn $555,000 $555,000 $432,000 22.2% 22.2%
2502706 Linden $639,900 $639,900 $500,000 21.9% 21.9%
2489654 Pompton Lakes $475,000 $459,000 $360,000 24.2% 21.6%
2224253 North Haledon $950,000 $950,000 $750,000 21.1% 21.1%
2453443 Boonton Town $399,000 $399,000 $315,000 21.1% 21.1%
2421292 City Of Orange $359,999 $289,900 $230,000 36.1% 20.7%
2443948 Newark $113,000 $113,000 $90,000 20.4% 20.4%
2485346 Mendham $5,250,000 $5,250,000 $4,190,000 20.2% 20.2%
2471673 Bernards $450,000 $500,000 $400,000 11.1% 20.0%
2448566 Clifton $305,000 $249,900 $200,000 34.4% 20.0%
2460071 Hopatcong $225,000 $179,900 $144,000 36.0% 20.0%
2503446 Hanover $560,000 $560,000 $450,000 19.6% 19.6%
2457470 Byram $239,000 $217,000 $175,000 26.8% 19.4%
2491120 East Orange $285,000 $285,000 $230,000 19.3% 19.3%
2480334 Mahwah $10,995,000 $10,995,000 $8,875,000 19.3% 19.3%
2506166 West Milford $139,000 $139,000 $112,500 19.1% 19.1%
2349974 Franklin $370,000 $370,000 $300,000 18.9% 18.9%
2413793 Roselle $289,000 $209,000 $170,000 41.2% 18.7%
2446157 Rockaway $675,000 $675,000 $550,000 18.5% 18.5%
2401966 Parsippany-Troy Hills $480,000 $325,000 $265,000 44.8% 18.5%
2416190 Mountain Lakes $2,345,000 $2,345,000 $1,915,000 18.3% 18.3%
2455999 Carlstadt $440,000 $440,000 $360,000 18.2% 18.2%
2496223 Wayne $324,900 $324,900 $266,000 18.1% 18.1%
2455932 Hanover $469,990 $469,990 $385,000 18.1% 18.1%
2458446 Passaic $349,000 $299,000 $245,000 29.8% 18.1%
2498374 Bernards $375,000 $365,000 $300,000 20.0% 17.8%
2505536 Linden $219,000 $219,000 $180,000 17.8% 17.8%
2465396 Clifton $255,000 $255,000 $210,000 17.6% 17.6%
2484591 East Orange $339,900 $339,900 $280,000 17.6% 17.6%
2460883 Plainfield $169,900 $84,900 $70,000 58.8% 17.6%
2472462 Wayne $48,500 $48,500 $40,000 17.5% 17.5%
2491675 Roselle $225,000 $199,900 $165,000 26.7% 17.5%
2472009 Warren $1,210,000 $1,210,000 $999,950 17.4% 17.4%
2472867 Delaware $2,975,000 $2,975,000 $2,462,500 17.2% 17.2%
2457900 Middlesex $325,000 $280,000 $232,000 28.6% 17.1%
2471028 Harding $1,869,000 $1,869,000 $1,550,000 17.1% 17.1%
2488165 Parsippany-Troy Hills $376,000 $349,000 $290,000 22.9% 16.9%
2366818 Wantage $349,900 $249,900 $208,000 40.6% 16.8%
2454633 Lodi $255,000 $210,000 $175,000 31.4% 16.7%
2442812 Raritan $499,000 $479,900 $400,000 19.8% 16.6%
2448905 Edison $359,900 $359,900 $300,000 16.6% 16.6%
2485109 Wayne $369,900 $329,900 $275,000 25.7% 16.6%
2468920 Lodi $299,900 $299,900 $250,000 16.6% 16.6%
2471565 Hawthorne $249,900 $239,900 $200,000 20.0% 16.6%
2355768 Vernon $204,900 $149,900 $125,000 39.0% 16.6%
2454880 Belleville $289,900 $289,900 $241,900 16.6% 16.6%
2474943 West Orange $315,000 $299,000 $250,000 20.6% 16.4%
2509787 Morristown $230,000 $215,000 $180,000 21.7% 16.3%
2487414 Bridgewater $429,900 $429,900 $360,000 16.3% 16.3%
2501343 Rockaway $275,000 $275,000 $231,000 16.0% 16.0%
2473355 Hillsborough $250,000 $250,000 $210,000 16.0% 16.0%
2508461 Warren $249,900 $249,900 $210,000 16.0% 16.0%
2463613 Plainfield $339,000 $339,000 $285,000 15.9% 15.9%
2480422 Newark $119,900 $99,900 $84,000 29.9% 15.9%
2425444 Hardyston $374,500 $374,500 $315,000 15.9% 15.9%
2498112 Millburn $2,850,000 $2,850,000 $2,400,000 15.8% 15.8%
2424012 East Hanover $649,000 $599,000 $505,000 22.2% 15.7%
2476549 Kenilworth $439,000 $385,000 $325,000 26.0% 15.6%
2431660 Newark $159,900 $159,900 $135,000 15.6% 15.6%
2471581 Plainfield $249,000 $225,000 $190,000 23.7% 15.6%
2479843 Lopatcong $229,900 $199,900 $169,000 26.5% 15.5%
2479206 Rahway $205,900 $195,000 $165,000 19.9% 15.4%
2408004 Roselle Park $319,000 $319,000 $270,000 15.4% 15.4%
2462011 Bridgewater $259,900 $259,900 $220,000 15.4% 15.4%
2456011 Franklin Lakes $2,950,000 $2,950,000 $2,500,000 15.3% 15.3%
2494749 Maplewood $1,295,000 $1,295,000 $1,100,000 15.1% 15.1%
2499337 Montville $1,175,000 $1,175,000 $999,000 15.0% 15.0%





If you prefer to look at Lowball from a dollar discount perspective, here you go. The cutoff is successful lowball offers of $150,000 or more off the original list price:

MLS# Town OLP LP SP % off OLP % off OLP
2480334 Mahwah $10,995,000 $10,995,000 $8,875,000 19.3% $2,120,000
2397095 Franklin Lakes $5,175,000 $4,299,000 $3,750,000 27.5% $1,425,000
2485346 Mendham $5,250,000 $5,250,000 $4,190,000 20.2% $1,060,000
2426445 Watchung $3,450,000 $3,150,000 $2,700,000 21.7% $750,000
2408177 Berkeley Heights $2,200,000 $1,500,000 $1,450,000 34.1% $750,000
2441948 Bedminster $2,895,000 $2,350,000 $2,200,000 24.0% $695,000
2472867 Delaware $2,975,000 $2,975,000 $2,462,500 17.2% $512,500
2498112 Millburn $2,850,000 $2,850,000 $2,400,000 15.8% $450,000
2456011 Franklin Lakes $2,950,000 $2,950,000 $2,500,000 15.3% $450,000
2492046 Bernards $2,375,000 $2,195,000 $1,925,000 18.9% $450,000
2416292 North Caldwell $2,290,000 $1,999,890 $1,850,000 19.2% $440,000
2416190 Mountain Lakes $2,345,000 $2,345,000 $1,915,000 18.3% $430,000
2406518 Pequannock $1,370,000 $1,100,000 $950,000 30.7% $420,000
2503483 Millburn $3,999,999 $3,999,999 $3,600,000 10.0% $399,999
2479373 Harding $3,395,000 $3,395,000 $3,000,000 11.6% $395,000
2480857 Millburn $1,900,000 $1,599,000 $1,511,000 20.5% $389,000
2398407 Morris $1,295,000 $949,000 $925,000 28.6% $370,000
2490155 Washington $1,450,000 $1,275,000 $1,100,000 24.1% $350,000
2419877 Bridgewater $1,325,000 $1,090,000 $975,000 26.4% $350,000
2463816 Franklin Lakes $2,499,000 $2,350,000 $2,150,000 14.0% $349,000
2467835 Wyckoff $1,649,000 $1,329,000 $1,300,000 21.2% $349,000
2477338 Sparta $1,385,000 $1,095,000 $1,052,000 24.0% $333,000
2435316 Bernardsville $1,325,000 $1,095,000 $999,000 24.6% $326,000
2471028 Harding $1,869,000 $1,869,000 $1,550,000 17.1% $319,000
2476894 Franklin Lakes $2,999,000 $2,999,000 $2,685,000 10.5% $314,000
2397590 Ridgewood Village $1,079,000 $799,900 $765,000 29.1% $314,000
2452596 Summit City* $1,750,000 $1,500,000 $1,450,000 17.1% $300,000
2412975 Chester $1,374,900 $1,175,000 $1,085,000 21.1% $289,900
2413237 Upper Saddle River $1,399,000 $1,249,000 $1,120,000 19.9% $279,000
2440359 Kinnelon $900,000 $675,000 $625,000 30.6% $275,000
2482457 Montclair $1,100,000 $825,000 $825,000 25.0% $275,000
2409821 Montville $1,795,000 $1,695,000 $1,525,000 15.0% $270,000
2484047 Mountain Lakes $1,379,999 $1,169,000 $1,117,499 19.0% $262,500
2437559 Westfield $1,899,000 $1,749,000 $1,640,000 13.6% $259,000
2437714 Bernardsville $1,120,000 $949,500 $862,500 23.0% $257,500
2417811 Fairfield $984,900 $799,900 $735,000 25.4% $249,900
2460289 Berkeley Heights $1,300,000 $1,199,900 $1,060,000 18.5% $240,000
2437690 Scotch Plains $1,228,000 $1,099,000 $990,000 19.4% $238,000
2421033 Roseland $835,000 $640,000 $600,000 28.1% $235,000
2489538 Montclair $3,850,000 $3,850,000 $3,622,000 5.9% $228,000
2489060 Montclair $975,000 $848,000 $750,000 23.1% $225,000
2438076 Tewksbury $1,299,000 $1,150,000 $1,080,000 16.9% $219,000
2401966 Parsippany-Troy Hills $480,000 $325,000 $265,000 44.8% $215,000
2390061 Allendale $1,175,000 $989,000 $960,000 18.3% $215,000
2452827 Franklin Lakes $1,289,000 $1,199,000 $1,075,000 16.6% $214,000
2408448 Wyckoff $499,900 $399,000 $286,400 42.7% $213,500
2472009 Warren $1,210,000 $1,210,000 $999,950 17.4% $210,050
2471951 Millburn $1,479,000 $1,425,000 $1,270,000 14.1% $209,000
2489628 Westfield $2,099,000 $1,890,000 $1,890,000 10.0% $209,000
2487364 Millburn $2,895,000 $2,895,000 $2,690,000 7.1% $205,000
2437485 Randolph $1,125,000 $950,000 $922,500 18.0% $202,500
2224253 North Haledon $950,000 $950,000 $750,000 21.1% $200,000
2330685 Franklin Lakes $2,899,999 $2,799,999 $2,700,000 6.9% $199,999
2324961 Hillsborough $899,900 $749,900 $700,000 22.2% $199,900
2459932 Saddle River $1,999,000 $1,999,000 $1,800,000 10.0% $199,000
2457635 Millburn $2,099,000 $2,099,000 $1,900,000 9.5% $199,000
2476769 Wyckoff $2,299,000 $2,299,000 $2,100,000 8.7% $199,000
2471601 Westfield $1,499,000 $1,399,000 $1,300,000 13.3% $199,000
2494749 Maplewood $1,295,000 $1,295,000 $1,100,000 15.1% $195,000
2493630 Tewksbury $1,695,000 $1,695,000 $1,500,000 11.5% $195,000
2416967 Upper Saddle River $995,000 $895,000 $800,000 19.6% $195,000
2496171 Summit $2,995,000 $2,995,000 $2,800,000 6.5% $195,000
2424441 Morristown $849,000 $699,000 $655,000 22.9% $194,000
2458066 Bernards $1,289,000 $1,289,000 $1,100,000 14.7% $189,000
2488430 Morris $1,437,000 $1,337,500 $1,250,000 13.0% $187,000
2446850 Bridgewater $1,175,000 $1,075,000 $990,000 15.7% $185,000
2511976 Westfield $1,659,000 $1,659,000 $1,475,000 11.1% $184,000
2492878 Livingston $1,429,000 $1,299,000 $1,245,000 12.9% $184,000
2406303 Hawthorne $729,900 $595,000 $550,000 24.6% $179,900
2503753 Madison $2,279,000 $2,279,000 $2,100,000 7.9% $179,000
2499337 Montville $1,175,000 $1,175,000 $999,000 15.0% $176,000
2453239 Elizabeth $525,000 $399,900 $350,000 33.3% $175,000
2465937 Franklin Lakes $1,350,000 $1,325,000 $1,175,000 13.0% $175,000
2474946 Montville $1,450,000 $1,399,000 $1,275,000 12.1% $175,000
2447807 Denville $424,900 $349,000 $251,500 40.8% $173,400
2489166 Millburn $1,195,000 $1,195,000 $1,025,000 14.2% $170,000
2446861 Washington $749,000 $649,900 $580,000 22.6% $169,000
2471827 Bernards $1,595,000 $1,595,000 $1,430,000 10.3% $165,000
2283827 Warren $1,104,950 $935,000 $940,000 14.9% $164,950
2439497 South Orange Village $839,900 $719,000 $675,000 19.6% $164,900
2443225 Hohokus $599,000 $499,000 $435,000 27.4% $164,000
2409478 Livingston $789,000 $695,000 $625,000 20.8% $164,000
2499359 Montclair $1,275,000 $1,275,000 $1,112,500 12.7% $162,500
2402761 Summit City* $551,500 $399,999 $390,000 29.3% $161,500
2440529 Raritan $950,000 $875,000 $790,000 16.8% $160,000
2454542 Livingston $729,000 $649,000 $570,000 21.8% $159,000
2473620 Chatham $2,499,000 $2,499,000 $2,340,000 6.4% $159,000
2456402 Boonton Town $649,000 $499,000 $490,000 24.5% $159,000
2393054 Paterson $275,000 $174,900 $120,000 56.4% $155,000
2499523 Chatham $1,140,000 $1,099,000 $985,000 13.6% $155,000
2488575 Montclair $1,555,000 $1,555,000 $1,400,000 10.0% $155,000
2488647 Boonton $2,300,000 $2,400,000 $2,150,000 6.5% $150,000
2486040 Franklin Lakes $2,950,000 $2,950,000 $2,800,000 5.1% $150,000
2475050 Millburn $2,450,000 $2,350,000 $2,300,000 6.1% $150,000
2473892 Bridgewater $749,000 $599,000 $599,000 20.0% $150,000

John St, Ridgewood NJ


Purchased: 6/30/2006
Purchase Price: $795,000
Current Asking Price: $745,000

MLS# 2819679
Listed: 5/13/2008
List Price: $769,000
Reduced to: $745,000
Active

———————————–

Jerome Ave, Glen Rock NJ


Purchased: 11/7/2005
Purchase Price: $520,000
Current Asking Price: $479,000

MLS# 2723934
Listed: 5/13/2007
List Price: $549,000
Reduced to: $519,000
Withdrawn

MLS# 2809536
Listed: 3/9/2008
List Price: $500,000
Reduced to: $479,000
Active

———————————–

Harrington Street, Hillsdale NJ


Purchased: 3/7/2005
Purchase Price: $635,000
Current Asking Price: $599,000

MLS# 2723934
Listed: 6/11/2007
List Price: $689,000
Withdrawn

MLS# 2742492
Listed: 10/19/2007
List Price: $659,000
Reduced to: $639,000
Expired

MLS# 2817462
Listed: 4/29/2008
List Price: $638,500
Withdrawn

MLS# 2821719
Listed: 5/29/2008
List Price: $599,000
Active

———————————–

Woodland Cross, Westwood NJ


Purchased: 1/6/2006
Purchase Price: $630,000
Sold for: $570,000

MLS# 2748135
Listed: 12/10/2007
List Price: $659,000
Reduced to: $630,000
Withdrawn

MLS# 2808782
Listed: 3/4/2008
List Price: $629,000
Sold: $570,000
Sale Date: 5/27/2008

———————————–

Haworth Ave, Haworth NJ


Purchased: 6/6/2005
Purchase Price: $789,000
Current Asking Price: $769,000

MLS# 2804108
Listed: 1/30/2008
List Price: $829,000
Reduced to: $769,000
Withdrawn

MLS# 2821495
Listed: 5/27/2008
List Price: $769,000
Active

Welcome to another edition of Lowball!

Lowball! takes a look at home sales from a different perspective. For those new to Lowball!, a lowball offer is when a buyer offers a significantly lower bid than asking in hopes that the seller accepts the offer. We take a list of home sales from the past month and pick out the sales that have the highest percentage difference between original list price and selling price.

To keep the list length reasonable, we’re going to use 20% 25%! as the minimum percentage off OLP to be considered a Lowball!

Caveat Emptor!

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
2368994 Sussex Boro $205,000 $124,900 $70,000 65.9% $135,000
2411956 Lambertville City $325,000 $325,000 $140,000 56.9% $185,000
2453525 Long Hill Twp. $269,000 $195,000 $140,000 48.0% $129,000
2401728 Newark City $141,900 $84,900 $75,000 47.1% $66,900
2285518 Washington Twp. $295,000 $219,000 $170,000 42.4% $125,000
2414077 Nutley Twp. $359,900 $359,900 $212,500 41.0% $147,400
2417925 Washington Twp. $321,500 $229,900 $190,000 40.9% $131,500
2427746 Newark City $270,000 $240,000 $160,000 40.7% $110,000
2417836 Irvington Twp. $323,000 $223,000 $195,000 39.6% $128,000
2413605 East Orange City $190,000 $131,500 $115,000 39.5% $75,000
2428960 Hillsborough Twp. $369,500 $279,000 $225,000 39.1% $144,500
2403028 Franklin Boro $229,900 $179,900 $142,000 38.2% $87,900
2467296 Haledon Boro $369,900 $269,900 $230,000 37.8% $139,900
2463295 Pompton Lakes Boro $235,000 $169,900 $150,000 36.2% $85,000
2432852 Morris Twp. $299,900 $199,900 $193,000 35.6% $106,900
2449147 Flemington Boro $350,000 $250,000 $226,000 35.4% $124,000
2418742 Hillside Twp. $240,000 $215,000 $155,000 35.4% $85,000
2340584 Totowa Boro $1,998,000 $1,730,888 $1,300,000 34.9% $698,000
2434765 Rockaway Twp. $1,270,000 $1,270,000 $830,000 34.6% $440,000
2427557 Chester Twp. $1,395,000 $1,190,000 $920,000 34.1% $475,000
2336331 Glen Ridge Boro Twp. $1,099,000 $975,000 $725,010 34.0% $373,990
2418827 Phillipsburg Town $110,900 $79,900 $73,500 33.7% $37,400
2386089 Mansfield Twp. $360,000 $265,000 $239,000 33.6% $121,000
2386428 Wayne Twp. $424,900 $319,900 $285,000 32.9% $139,900
2321221 Edison Twp. $619,900 $450,000 $420,000 32.2% $199,900
2392687 Peapack Gladstone Boro $499,000 $399,000 $340,000 31.9% $159,000
2367804 Sparta Twp. $824,900 $599,900 $565,000 31.5% $259,900
2419649 Phillipsburg Town $108,900 $99,900 $75,000 31.1% $33,900
2417672 Watchung Boro $649,900 $535,000 $450,000 30.8% $199,900
2471011 Paterson City $98,000 $98,000 $68,000 30.6% $30,000
2453588 Saddle Brook Twp. $259,000 $239,000 $180,000 30.5% $79,000
2420485 Lebanon Twp. $329,900 $279,900 $230,000 30.3% $99,900
2438980 Westfield Twp. $258,000 $205,500 $180,000 30.2% $78,000
2433182 Irvington Twp. $190,000 $140,000 $132,600 30.2% $57,400
2341591 East Hanover Twp. $829,000 $619,000 $580,000 30.0% $249,000
2423572 City Of Orange Twp. $199,900 $179,900 $140,000 30.0% $59,900
2440094 Washington Twp. $249,000 $185,000 $175,000 29.7% $74,000
2440387 Morris Twp. $939,000 $750,000 $660,000 29.7% $279,000
2419769 Springfield Twp. $679,000 $519,900 $480,000 29.3% $199,000
2448562 Sparta Twp. $179,000 $159,000 $128,000 28.5% $51,000
2373884 North Caldwell Boro $1,250,000 $999,000 $900,000 28.0% $350,000
2379538 Hillsborough Twp. $449,900 $350,000 $325,000 27.8% $124,900
2415055 Haledon Boro $529,900 $449,900 $383,000 27.7% $146,900
2446625 Manville Boro $199,750 $199,750 $145,000 27.4% $54,750
2453066 Clifton City $249,000 $224,900 $181,000 27.3% $68,000
2424561 Bloomfield Twp. $405,000 $319,000 $295,000 27.2% $110,000
2410493 Mendham Twp. $3,400,000 $2,750,000 $2,500,000 26.5% $900,000
2393550 Franklin Lakes Boro $649,900 $539,900 $479,521 26.2% $170,379
2442598 Maplewood Twp. $1,350,000 $1,150,000 $999,000 26.0% $351,000
2436442 Hopatcong Boro $254,900 $195,000 $189,900 25.5% $65,000
2452266 Hampton Twp. $294,900 $294,900 $220,000 25.4% $74,900
2433101 North Plainfield Boro $315,000 $279,000 $235,000 25.4% $80,000
2410043 Clinton Twp. $389,900 $304,900 $292,000 25.1% $97,900
2462662 Elizabeth City $120,000 $120,000 $90,000 25.0% $30,000
2410944 South Orange Village Twp. $599,900 $579,900 $450,000 25.0% $149,900

And some high dollar amount lowballs that didn’t make the cutoff.

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
2283606 Bernardsville Boro $7,995,000 $6,850,000 $6,350,000 20.6% $1,645,000
2302094 North Caldwell Boro $3,099,000 $2,875,000 $2,500,000 19.3% $599,000
2435080 Madison Boro $2,200,000 $1,880,000 $1,675,000 23.9% $525,000
2388301 Tewksbury Twp. $2,095,000 $1,699,950 $1,611,600 23.1% $483,400
2424095 Millburn Twp. $3,195,000 $3,195,000 $2,725,000 14.7% $470,000
2382638 Glen Ridge Boro Twp. $1,895,000 $1,895,000 $1,450,000 23.5% $445,000
2447856 Millburn Twp. $3,250,000 $2,995,000 $2,825,000 13.1% $425,000
2410434 Saddle River Boro $5,195,000 $5,195,000 $4,800,000 7.6% $395,000
2414390 Madison Boro $2,150,000 $1,950,000 $1,775,000 17.4% $375,000
2441986 Warren Twp. $1,550,000 $1,275,000 $1,185,000 23.5% $365,000
2425332 Franklin Lakes Boro $1,699,000 $1,499,000 $1,360,000 20.0% $339,000
2431373 Mendham Twp. $2,399,000 $2,299,000 $2,075,000 13.5% $324,000
2413040 Kinnelon Boro $1,279,000 $1,050,000 $960,000 24.9% $319,000
2395890 Summit City $1,650,000 $1,550,000 $1,350,000 18.2% $300,000
2449497 Westfield Twp. $1,250,000 $1,099,000 $999,999 20.0% $250,001
2448139 Millburn Twp. $1,399,000 $1,295,000 $1,160,000 17.1% $239,000
2379221 Washington Twp. $929,900 $759,000 $710,000 23.6% $219,900
2418138 Montville Twp. $1,100,000 $995,000 $885,000 19.5% $215,000
2392418 Readington Twp. $924,000 $750,000 $715,000 22.6% $209,000
2390267 Washington Twp. $1,050,000 $860,000 $845,000 19.5% $205,000
2431140 Allendale Boro $1,350,000 $1,260,000 $1,150,000 14.8% $200,000
2378138 Peapack Gladstone Boro $799,000 $649,000 $600,000 24.9% $199,000
2403684 Franklin Lakes Boro $1,999,000 $1,865,000 $1,800,000 10.0% $199,000
2445489 Bridgewater Twp. $1,295,000 $1,175,000 $1,100,000 15.1% $195,000
2398670 Mendham Twp. $1,185,000 $1,145,000 $991,000 16.4% $194,000
2459051 Mahwah Twp. $1,367,000 $1,367,000 $1,175,000 14.0% $192,000
2427125 Readington Twp. $860,000 $725,000 $675,000 21.5% $185,000
2400671 West Orange Twp. $739,900 $579,000 $560,000 24.3% $179,900
2406270 Lake Mohawk Byram $850,000 $750,000 $675,000 20.6% $175,000
2438424 Essex Fells Twp. $1,090,000 $999,999 $925,000 15.1% $165,000
2396547 South Orange Village Twp. $799,500 $649,500 $639,000 20.1% $160,500
2448032 Scotch Plains Twp. $1,150,000 $1,100,000 $999,995 13.0% $150,005
2390993 Berkeley Heights Twp. $699,900 $569,900 $549,900 21.4% $150,000

From the Star Ledger:

The hard sell: Owners have trouble unloading N.J. homes

For James Bednar, the 29-year-old founder of the blog New Jersey Real Estate Report, there’s nothing like a game of “Lowball!” to get a sense of how buyers and sellers are behaving these days.

For those new to the game, it works like this: Every time a buyer makes an offer on a home that’s at least 20 percent below the original listing and the seller accepts it, Bednar takes note of it. Then, every month or so, he takes the most dramatic lowball deals and posts them on his blog.

Like the three-bedroom home on three acres in Watchung that originally listed for $975,000, then was reduced to $775,000 before finally being sold for $620,000. Or the five-bedroom in Mendham that was listed for $1.19 million back in March before being reduced to $949,00 and selling for $900,000 — after 236 days on the market.

“Two years ago… it was difficult for me to get even a handful of lowballs, maybe a dozen at most,” Bednar said. “But when I do the same analysis today, I get back 10 times that number.”

It’s little wonder sellers are getting desperate.

The pace of home sales in New Jersey slowed to a crawl in December, with the volume of sales contracts falling 31 percent year over year, according to Jeffrey Otteau, president of East Brunswick-based Otteau Valuation Group. Not all contracts result in a final sale.

The picture was more bleak in outlying counties such as Sussex and Warren, where “contract sales” were down 42 percent and 44 percent, respectively. “They’re not part of a rail corridor,” Otteau explained. “New Jersey housing is migrating to areas that are transportation efficient.”

Joseph Awad is one of the faces behind the abysmal housing statistics.

For the past nine months, Awad, 28, has been trying to sell the two-bedroom house in South Amboy he shares with his wife, Jennifer, 27, and their two children, Hailey, 3 and Nicholas, 11 months. Awad said he was hoping to relocate to North Carolina, because the cost of living there is cheaper than in New Jersey. But he has been unable to find a buyer for his gray, two-story home.

“I’ve had to put everything on hold,” said Awad, a desktop engineer who listed his home in March for $280,000. One month later, after getting no offers, he lowered the asking price to $269,000.

“From that point on, I was reducing the price every 30 days or so until I brought it down to $239,000,” Awad said, slightly more than what he paid for the house two years ago.

Awad eventually got two offers, but in the end, both deals fell through because the prospective buyers could not line up financing. At this point, Awad said he would be lucky to break even.

Others are not so lucky.

Multiple listing services, which publish directories of all properties for sale in New Jersey, are filled with examples of sellers foregoing a profit to unload their homes.

Bednar tracks such deals and posts them on his blog under the heading “Comp Killer” — homes that sell at such a discounted price they negatively effect the value of other properties in the area.

On Jan. 16, for example, a home in Pequannock sold for $550,000 — 11 percent below the price the seller paid for the property in 2005. A home in Watchung sold on Jan. 17 for $450,000 — 32 percent below what the homeowner had paid just last year.

“The marketplace has a crisis of confidence right now,” said Max Spann Jr., who operates a property auction company in Clinton. “People read in the newspaper that the market is bad. They talk to their neighbors. They see the ‘For sale’ signs out for months and months and months, and people are afraid to buy. They’re afraid to overpay.

“They’re afraid the market may go down further, so it has created paralysis.”

Welcome to another edition of Lowball!

Lowball! takes a look at home sales from a different perspective. For those new to Lowball!, a lowball offer is when a buyer offers a significantly lower bid than asking in hopes that the seller accepts the offer. We take a list of home sales from the past month and pick out the sales that have the highest percentage difference between original list price and selling price.

To keep the list length reasonable, we’re going to use 20% as the minimum percentage off OLP to be considered a Lowball!

Caveat Emptor!

Bergen County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 241277   Wyckoff Twp.  $1,200,000    $840,000    $772,000    35.7%   $428,000  
 240289   East Rutherford Boro  $630,000    $459,000    $435,000    31.0%   $195,000  
 237865   Franklin Lakes Boro  $2,950,000    $2,950,000    $2,112,500    28.4%   $837,500  
 240653   Fair Lawn Boro  $524,900    $424,000    $385,000    26.7%   $139,900  
 235346   Lyndhurst Twp.  $609,900    $489,000    $450,000    26.2%   $159,900  
 242097   Garfield City  $399,000    $349,000    $295,000    26.1%   $104,000  
 241453   Wyckoff Twp.  $1,250,000    $1,025,000    $965,000    22.8%   $285,000  
 230922   Ramsey Boro  $849,925    $669,925    $659,000    22.5%   $190,925  
 243769   Franklin Lakes Boro  $2,900,000    $2,900,000    $2,275,000    21.6%   $625,000  

Essex County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 240147   Newark City  $159,900    $84,900    $83,000    48.1%   $76,900  
 240172   Newark City  $141,900    $84,900    $75,000    47.1%   $66,900  
 241360   East Orange City  $190,000    $131,500    $115,000    39.5%   $75,000  
 241534   Livingston Twp.  $750,000    $500,000    $500,000    33.3%   $250,000  
 240451   Belleville Twp.  $194,900    $172,500    $136,000    30.2%   $58,900  
 243097   Millburn Twp.  $1,050,000    $1,050,000    $740,000    29.5%   $310,000  
 241921   North Caldwell Boro  $570,000    $499,900    $405,000    28.9%   $165,000  
 241309   Newark City  $259,900    $209,900    $190,000    26.9%   $69,900  
 237819   Bloomfield Twp.  $339,900    $289,900    $252,000    25.9%   $87,900  
 237719   Livingston Twp.  $799,000    $639,000    $595,000    25.5%   $204,000  
 243467   South Orange Village Twp.  $1,259,000    $998,900    $950,000    24.5%   $309,000  
 245075   Belleville Twp.  $378,170    $378,170    $288,170    23.8%   $90,000  
 244199   Newark City  $149,900    $124,900    $117,000    21.9%   $32,900  
 242822   Millburn Twp.  $729,000    $609,000    $570,000    21.8%   $159,000  
 239670   West Orange Twp.  $459,000    $378,876    $360,000    21.6%   $99,000  
 239608   Belleville Twp.  $455,000    $369,000    $358,000    21.3%   $97,000  
 241118   Fairfield Twp.  $539,000    $475,000    $425,000    21.2%   $114,000  
 244247   West Orange Twp.  $379,000    $359,000    $300,000    20.8%   $79,000  

Morris County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 232870   Chatham Twp.  $1,995,000    $1,495,000    $916,000    54.1%   $1,079,000  
 241989   Harding Twp.  $2,195,000    $1,600,000    $1,250,000    43.1%   $945,000  
 237165   Butler Boro  $399,900    $319,900    $270,000    32.5%   $129,900  
 240684   Montville Twp.  $1,225,000    $999,900    $860,000    29.8%   $365,000  
 244038   Morris Twp.  $939,000    $750,000    $660,000    29.7%   $279,000  
 241269   Riverdale Boro  $355,000    $290,000    $255,000    28.2%   $100,000  
 242074   Lincoln Park Boro  $349,900    $259,900    $255,000    27.1%   $94,900  
 242169   Denville Twp.  $310,000    $284,900    $230,000    25.8%   $80,000  
 238321   Mendham Twp.  $1,199,000    $949,000    $900,000    24.9%   $299,000  
 232932   Randolph Twp.  $550,000    $435,000    $415,000    24.5%   $135,000  
 239620   Denville Twp.  $429,999    $334,900    $325,000    24.4%   $104,999  
 242631   Chester Boro  $525,000    $450,000    $400,000    23.8%   $125,000  
 236764   Dover Town  $359,900    $299,900    $275,000    23.6%   $84,900  
 241150   Netcong Boro  $299,900    $225,000    $230,000    23.3%   $69,900  
 242580   Lincoln Park Boro  $405,000    $329,900    $315,000    22.2%   $90,000  
 240309   Parsippany-Troy Hills Twp.  $399,900    $337,500    $315,000    21.2%   $84,900  
 239036   Mount Olive Twp.  $459,000    $390,000    $365,000    20.5%   $94,000  
 241513   Wharton Boro  $249,900    $215,000    $198,940    20.4%   $50,960  

Passaic County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 236418   Wayne Twp.  $169,900    $79,900    $55,000    67.6%   $114,900  
 241630   Wayne Twp.  $69,900    $69,900    $45,160    35.4%   $24,740  
 241505   Haledon Boro  $529,900    $449,900    $383,000    27.7%   $146,900  
 241396   Pompton Lakes Boro  $419,900    $345,000    $305,000    27.4%   $114,900  
 241642   Passaic City  $289,000    $229,900    $215,000    25.6%   $74,000  
 240484   West Milford Twp.  $135,000    $135,000    $103,000    23.7%   $32,000  
 239170   Wayne Twp.  $1,389,000    $1,199,900    $1,085,000    21.9%   $304,000  
 243664   Wayne Twp.  $924,900    $799,999    $725,000    21.6%   $199,900  
 243473   Hawthorne Boro  $489,000    $429,900    $385,000    21.3%   $104,000  
 242706   Clifton City  $389,900    $359,000    $310,000    20.5%   $79,900  
 239972   Paterson City  $439,900    $380,000    $350,000    20.4%   $89,900  

Somerset County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 2451946   Watchung Boro  $975,000    $775,000    $620,000    36.4%   $355,000  
 2392687   Peapack Gladstone Boro  $499,000    $399,000    $340,000    31.9%   $159,000  
 2416743   Hillsborough Twp.  $374,900    $299,900    $277,500    26.0%   $97,400  
 2433101   North Plainfield Boro  $315,000    $279,000    $235,000    25.4%   $80,000  
 2446635   Bound Brook Boro  $310,000    $274,900    $235,000    24.2%   $75,000  
 2403792   Bridgewater Twp.  $560,000    $455,000    $427,000    23.8%   $133,000  
 2396187   Watchung Boro  $1,499,000    $1,499,000    $1,155,000    22.9%   $344,000  
 2418420   Bound Brook Boro  $339,900    $299,900    $265,000    22.0%   $74,900  

Sussex County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 2236725   Fredon Twp.  $1,100,000    $890,000    $675,000    38.6%   $425,000  
 2425734   Newton Town  $334,900    $219,900    $219,000    34.6%   $115,900  
 2418768   Hopatcong Boro  $384,900    $269,900    $265,000    31.2%   $119,900  
 2419901   Stillwater Twp.  $299,999    $229,000    $219,900    26.7%   $80,099  
 2306895   Andover Boro  $319,000    $299,000    $236,000    26.0%   $83,000  
 2323293   Hardyston Twp.  $679,900    $549,000    $508,000    25.3%   $171,900  
 2421170   Byram Twp.  $354,900    $294,900    $265,920    25.1%   $88,980  
 2423114   Byram Twp.  $319,000    $263,000    $243,000    23.8%   $76,000  
 2395268   Hopatcong Boro  $399,997    $329,000    $305,000    23.7%   $94,997  
 2408464   Vernon Twp.  $265,000    $229,900    $205,000    22.6%   $60,000  
 2370721   Hampton Twp.  $319,900    $280,000    $250,000    21.9%   $69,900  
 2415402   Hampton Twp.  $274,900    $240,000    $215,000    21.8%   $59,900  
 2409837   Frankford Twp.  $239,000    $197,000    $187,500    21.5%   $51,500  
 2411234   Vernon Twp.  $275,000    $229,000    $217,000    21.1%   $58,000  
 2451599   Lafayette Twp.  $283,000    $274,000    $225,000    20.5%   $58,000  

Hunterdon County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 2367977   Hampton Boro  $325,000    $245,000    $240,000    26.2%   $85,000  
 2399454   Clinton Twp.  $550,000    $479,900    $409,000    25.6%   $141,000  
 2410043   Clinton Twp.  $389,900    $304,900    $292,000    25.1%   $97,900  
 2388301   Tewksbury Twp.  $2,095,000    $1,699,950    $1,611,600    23.1%   $483,400  
 2392418   Readington Twp.  $924,000    $750,000    $715,000    22.6%   $209,000  
 2443444   High Bridge Boro  $242,000    $229,900    $190,000    21.5%   $52,000  
 2428687   East Amwell Twp.  $347,500    $309,900    $275,000    20.9%   $72,500  
 2400049   Readington Twp.  $575,000    $525,000    $460,000    20.0%   $115,000  

Warren County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 2414608   Phillipsburg Town  $116,900    $69,900    $33,000    71.8%   $83,900  
 2368439   Washington Twp.  $301,900    $214,900    $195,000    35.4%   $106,900  
 2430255   Belvidere Twp.  $94,900    $79,900    $65,000    31.5%   $29,900  
 2446890   Oxford Twp.  $26,000    $22,000    $19,000    26.9%   $7,000  
 2380755   Frelinghuysen Twp.  $599,000    $479,000    $447,500    25.3%   $151,500  
 2424875   Washington Twp.  $249,000    $199,999    $192,000    22.9%   $57,000  
 2431122   Blairstown Twp.  $324,900    $289,900    $255,000    21.5%   $69,900  
 2365615   Franklin Twp.  $225,000    $225,000    $180,000    20.0%   $45,000  

Union County

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 2436996   Elizabeth City  $499,999    $350,000    $300,000    40.0%   $199,999  
 2452459   Springfield Twp.  $499,999    $349,999    $321,000    35.8%   $178,999  
 2419493   Union Twp.  $468,850    $369,850    $340,000    27.5%   $128,850  
 2409663   Plainfield City  $232,000    $169,000    $169,000    27.2%   $63,000  
 2434622   New Providence Boro  $579,000    $500,000    $425,000    26.6%   $154,000  
 2242383   Roselle Boro  $324,900    $249,900    $240,000    26.1%   $84,900  
 2318447   Elizabeth City  $344,900    $279,900    $260,000    24.6%   $84,900  
 2391449   Elizabeth City  $440,000    $369,000    $338,000    23.2%   $102,000  
 2412073   Cranford Twp.  $485,000    $419,000    $375,000    22.7%   $110,000  
 2439139   Elizabeth City  $400,000    $400,000    $310,000    22.5%   $90,000  
 2426297   Berkeley Heights Twp.  $665,000    $549,000    $525,000    21.1%   $140,000  
 2250306   Elizabeth City  $415,000    $379,900    $330,000    20.5%   $85,000  
 2444710   Rahway City  $274,900    $249,900    $220,000    20.0%   $54,900  

Welcome to another edition of Lowball!

Lowball! takes a look at home sales from a different perspective. For those new to Lowball!, a lowball offer is when a buyer offers a significantly lower bid than asking in hopes that the seller accepts the offer. We take a list of home sales from the past month and pick out the sales that have the highest percentage difference between original list price and selling price.

Since I haven’t done a Lowball! in a few months, there is quite a bit of data to be displayed. To make it easier to post, as well as easier on me, I’m going to post these up on a county-by-county basis over the next few days. We’re going to start with Bergen, and move through the counties alphabetically. Keep in mind the Bergen Lowball! sales are sourced from GSMLS, not NJMLS, so a significant number of sales are missing from the data.

On to the list!

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
2337734 Hackensack City $1,175,000 $925,000 $850,000 27.7% $325,000
2389558 Ramsey Boro $1,250,000 $999,938 $950,000 24.0% $300,000
2345985 Garfield City $319,900 $265,000 $245,000 23.4% $74,900
2383480 Ridgewood Village $729,900 $565,000 $560,000 23.3% $169,900
2392716 Oakland Boro $444,500 $359,900 $350,000 21.3% $94,500
2352992 Fair Lawn Boro $400,000 $300,000 $318,000 20.5% $82,000
2359059 Oakland Boro $419,000 $375,000 $335,000 20.0% $84,000
2370524 Glen Rock Boro $1,245,000 $1,073,000 $998,000 19.8% $247,000
2363313 Glen Rock Boro $1,150,000 $1,050,000 $930,000 19.1% $220,000
2351448 Wyckoff Twp. $799,900 $699,000 $650,000 18.7% $149,900
2288917 Franklin Lakes $719,900 $639,000 $585,000 18.7% $134,900
2239795 Fair Lawn Boro $369,000 $337,900 $300,000 18.7% $69,000
2304593 Rutherford Boro $599,000 $525,000 $490,000 18.2% $109,000
2343246 Ridgewood Village $689,000 $599,900 $565,000 18.0% $124,000
2379258 Harrington Park $634,900 $536,000 $521,000 17.9% $113,900
2366677 Hillsdale Boro $999,000 $849,900 $825,000 17.4% $174,000
2381954 Ridgewood Village $575,000 $500,000 $475,000 17.4% $100,000
2373561 Garfield City $399,000 $379,900 $330,000 17.3% $69,000
2385159 Fair Lawn Boro $409,900 $369,900 $340,000 17.1% $69,900
2387977 Fair Lawn Boro $239,000 $219,000 $200,000 16.3% $39,000
2326403 Waldwick Boro $639,000 $599,000 $535,000 16.3% $104,000
2359581 Fair Lawn Boro $739,000 $649,000 $620,000 16.1% $119,000
2344733 Saddle River Boro $2,499,000 $2,299,000 $2,100,000 16.0% $399,000
2396552 Ridgewood Village $1,495,000 $1,385,000 $1,260,000 15.7% $235,000
2388007 Fair Lawn Boro $239,000 $219,000 $201,500 15.7% $37,500
2370727 Rutherford Boro $258,900 $238,000 $219,000 15.4% $39,900
2409191 Franklin Lakes $1,999,900 $1,999,900 $1,700,000 15.0% $299,900
2327838 Waldwick Boro $599,000 $529,900 $510,000 14.9% $89,000
2328085 Tenafly Boro $1,387,000 $1,255,000 $1,190,000 14.2% $197,000
2384248 Oakland Boro $739,900 $739,900 $635,000 14.2% $104,900
2304254 Oakland Boro $529,900 $469,900 $455,000 14.1% $74,900
2320344 Mahwah Twp. $559,000 $524,000 $480,000 14.1% $79,000
2409177 Emerson Boro $899,900 $849,900 $775,000 13.9% $124,900
2412730 Franklin Lakes $8,445,000 $8,445,000 $7,300,000 13.6% $1.145m
2370198 Ridgewood Village $925,000 $795,000 $800,000 13.5% $125,000
2318280 Paramus Boro $379,000 $349,900 $330,000 12.9% $49,000
2398117 Lodi Boro $327,000 $319,000 $285,000 12.8% $42,000
2387315 Garfield City $389,900 $369,900 $340,000 12.8% $49,900
2395588 Ridgewood Village $749,000 $699,000 $655,000 12.6% $94,000
2300974 Mahwah Twp. $849,000 $774,900 $742,500 12.5% $106,500
2372219 Rochelle Park Twp. $479,900 $439,900 $420,000 12.5% $59,900
2402380 Glen Rock Boro $439,900 $424,900 $385,000 12.5% $54,900
2378161 Wyckoff Twp. $899,900 $825,000 $789,000 12.3% $110,900
2390180 Wyckoff Twp. $815,000 $749,900 $714,800 12.3% $100,200
2304941 Saddle Brook Twp. $469,900 $445,000 $412,500 12.2% $57,400
2384515 Wyckoff Twp. $1,195,000 $1,135,000 $1,050,000 12.1% $145,000
2399768 Midland Park Boro $995,000 $919,000 $875,000 12.1% $120,000
2392235 Oakland Boro $699,000 $629,000 $615,000 12.0% $84,000
2390143 Allendale Boro $1,079,000 $989,000 $950,000 12.0% $129,000
2366817 Waldwick Boro $464,900 $435,000 $410,000 11.8% $54,900
2363581 Ridgewood Village $1,700,000 $1,700,000 $1,500,000 11.8% $200,000
2325320 Allendale Boro $699,000 $619,000 $620,000 11.3% $79,000
2378810 Wyckoff Twp. $689,000 $649,000 $612,000 11.2% $77,000
2320022 Upper Saddle River $1,095,000 $999,900 $975,000 11.0% $120,000
2316931 Rutherford Boro $480,000 $460,000 $427,500 10.9% $52,500
2381664 Ridgewood Village $595,000 $565,000 $530,000 10.9% $65,000
2335667 Waldwick Boro $425,000 $385,000 $379,812 10.6% $45,188
2383061 Oakland Boro $575,000 $525,000 $514,000 10.6% $61,000
2359654 River Edge Boro $559,000 $537,000 $500,000 10.6% $59,000
2382077 Ridgewood Village $689,999 $639,000 $617,500 10.5% $72,499
2366742 Ramsey Boro $550,000 $518,000 $493,000 10.4% $57,000
2417655 Elmwood Park $484,900 $465,000 $435,000 10.3% $49,900
2319779 Upper Saddle River $924,900 $849,900 $830,000 10.3% $94,900
2379186 Mahwah Twp.* $919,000 $850,000 $825,000 10.2% $94,000
2415583 Fair Lawn Boro $529,000 $499,000 $475,000 10.2% $54,000
2379809 Tenafly Boro $739,000 $669,000 $664,000 10.1% $75,000
2362254 North Arlington Boro $345,000 $310,000 $310,000 10.1% $35,000
2294893 Wyckoff Twp. $739,900 $739,900 $665,000 10.1% $74,900
2385816 Wyckoff Twp. $839,900 $839,900 $755,000 10.1% $84,900
2380369 Upper Saddle River $1,099,000 $1,099,000 $989,000 10.0% $110,000
2413091 Ridgewood Village $524,900 $499,000 $472,500 10.0% $52,400
2391823 Garfield City $399,900 $389,000 $360,000 10.0% $39,900

Welcome to another edition of Lowball!

Lowball! takes a look at home sales from a different perspective. For those new to Lowball!, a lowball offer is when a buyer offers a significantly lower bid than asking in hopes that the seller accepts the offer. We take a list of home sales from the past month and pick out the sales that have the highest percentage difference between original list price and selling price.

The purpose of Lowball! is to show buyers that the market has changed and buyers now have considerably more leverage than sellers. Just a short time ago, Lowball! offers would have been laughed at and discarded, however, not any more. The fact that so many under-asking offers are being accepted is clear proof that the market is changing.

MLS Town OLP LP SP % off OLP $ off OLP
 2363053   East Orange City  $169,900    $67,900    $63,000    62.9%   $106,900  
 2343436   Branchburg Twp.  $25,000    $17,000    $13,500    46.0%   $11,500  
 2335411   White Twp.  $99,900    $69,000    $55,500    44.4%   $44,400  
 2388027   Montague Twp.*  $262,500    $159,900    $159,900    39.1%   $102,600  
 2359771   Phillipsburg Town*  $120,000    $95,000    $75,000    37.5%   $45,000  
 2358403   Elizabeth City*  $419,900    $299,900    $265,000    36.9%   $154,900  
 2323942   City Of Orange Twp.*  $239,900    $158,999    $153,000    36.2%   $86,900  
 2311072   West Milford Twp.  $318,501    $225,000    $210,000    34.1%   $108,501  
 2040082   Montville Twp.  $799,000    $649,000    $537,000    32.8%   $262,000  
 2342858   Jersey City*  $235,500    $177,500    $161,000    31.6%   $74,500  
 2367803   Paterson City*  $362,500    $259,900    $250,000    31.0%   $112,500  
 2278330   Millburn Twp.  $3,195,000    $2,540,000    $2,215,000    30.7%   $980,000  
 2354260   East Orange City  $230,000    $210,000    $160,000    30.4%   $70,000  
 2310008   Newark City  $230,000    $170,000    $160,000    30.4%   $70,000  
 2338764   Vernon Twp.  $236,500    $175,000    $165,000    30.2%   $71,500  
 2381569   Summit City  $669,000    $469,000    $469,000    29.9%   $200,000  
 2291434   Lambertville City*  $323,400    $254,000    $230,000    28.9%   $93,400  
 2384074   Bedminster Twp.  $354,900    $254,900    $253,000    28.7%   $101,900  
 2261925   Edison Twp.  $419,900    $319,900    $300,000    28.6%   $119,900  
 2327519   West Milford Twp.*  $424,900    $319,900    $305,000    28.2%   $119,900  
 2333550   Caldwell Boro Twp.  $535,000    $415,900    $385,000    28.0%   $150,000  
 2326900   Springfield Twp.  $485,000    $379,900    $350,000    27.8%   $135,000  
 2381653   Woodbridge Twp.*  $414,000    $314,000    $300,000    27.5%   $114,000  
 2336362   Glen Ridge Boro Twp.  $999,000    $790,000    $727,000    27.2%   $272,000  
 2329811   Roselle Boro*  $409,900    $300,000    $300,000    26.8%   $109,900  
 2303748   Rocky Hill Boro*  $439,900    $339,999    $322,000    26.8%   $117,900  
 2248078   West Orange Twp.  $599,900    $455,900    $440,000    26.7%   $159,900  
 2304099   Morris Twp.  $1,495,000    $1,149,000    $1,100,000    26.4%   $395,000  
 2351070   Lopatcong Twp.  $209,900    $164,900    $154,500    26.4%   $55,400  
 2393638   Roselle Boro  $275,000    $250,000    $202,500    26.4%   $72,500  
 2318656   South Orange Village  $1,351,080    $999,999    $999,999    26.0%   $351,081  
 2353613   Millburn Twp.  $2,695,000    $2,125,000    $2,000,000    25.8%   $695,000  
 2320749   Ogdensburg Boro  $333,000    $259,000    $247,200    25.8%   $85,800  
 2385843   South Bound Brook  $254,900    $254,900    $190,000    25.5%   $64,900  
 2336039   Jefferson Twp.*  $435,000    $425,000    $325,000    25.3%   $110,000  
 2379470   Paterson City*  $179,900    $150,000    $135,000    25.0%   $44,900  
 2387981   Piscataway Twp.*  $472,500    $339,900    $355,000    24.9%   $117,500  
 2287822   Mendham Boro  $585,000    $460,000    $440,000    24.8%   $145,000  
 2270294   Madison Boro*  $525,000    $399,999    $395,000    24.8%   $130,000  
 2288631   Ogdensburg Boro  $339,900    $299,000    $256,500    24.5%   $83,400  
 2388493   Elizabeth City  $204,900    $204,900    $155,000    24.4%   $49,900  
 2353189   Vernon Twp.*  $349,000    $265,000    $265,000    24.1%   $84,000  
 2333985   Old Bridge Twp.  $207,000    $189,000    $157,500    23.9%   $49,500  
 2322258   Pequannock Twp.  $499,000    $439,000    $380,000    23.8%   $119,000  
 2372169   East Orange City  $112,875    $95,545    $86,000    23.8%   $26,875  
 2346078   Franklin Twp.*  $195,999    $179,900    $150,000    23.5%   $45,999  
 2285801   Franklin Lakes Boro  $1,995,000    $1,699,000    $1,530,000    23.3%   $465,000  
 2259194   Millburn Twp.  $1,595,000    $1,349,000    $1,225,000    23.2%   $370,000  
 2326177   Passaic City  $395,000    $335,000    $305,000    22.8%   $90,000  
 2365258   Maplewood Twp.  $549,900    $495,900    $425,000    22.7%   $124,900  
 2284548   Mendham Boro  $565,000    $449,950    $440,000    22.1%   $125,000  
 2347438   Franklin Boro  $79,500    $65,000    $62,000    22.0%   $17,500  
 2314194   Hillsborough Twp.  $525,000    $460,000    $410,000    21.9%   $115,000  
 2298241   East Orange City  $199,900    $150,000    $156,200    21.9%   $43,700  
 2351110   West Milford Twp.  $248,900    $224,900    $195,000    21.7%   $53,900  
 2339321   Clifton City  $389,000    $329,900    $305,000    21.6%   $84,000  
 2289139   Paterson City  $184,900    $149,900    $145,000    21.6%   $39,900  
 2359926   Paterson City  $148,900    $129,000    $117,000    21.4%   $31,900  
 2280286   Hardyston Twp.  $349,900    $279,900    $275,000    21.4%   $74,900  
 2361272   Fairfield Twp.  $449,900    $370,800    $355,000    21.1%   $94,900  
 2280124   Edison Twp.*  $658,000    $529,000    $520,000    21.0%   $138,000  
 2385914   Bridgewater Twp.*  $309,900    $299,900    $245,000    20.9%   $64,900  
 2290258   Newark City*  $360,000    $319,900    $285,000    20.8%   $75,000  
 2380205   Ringwood Boro  $239,900    $239,900    $190,000    20.8%   $49,900  
 2331386   Linden City  $265,000    $210,100    $210,100    20.7%   $54,900  
 2325085   Springfield Twp.*  $614,500    $519,000    $487,500    20.7%   $127,000  
 2405957   Bridgewater Twp.*  $189,000    $189,000    $150,000    20.6%   $39,000  
 2319474   Nutley Twp.*  $849,900    $689,000    $675,000    20.6%   $174,900  
 2370225   Bloomfield Twp.  $339,900    $275,000    $270,000    20.6%   $69,900  
 2283696   Allamuchy Twp.  $439,900    $380,000    $350,000    20.4%   $89,900  
 2267873   Franklin Lakes Boro  $1,200,000    $1,099,000    $957,000    20.3%   $243,000  
 2364336   Pohatcong Twp.  $699,000    $569,000    $558,000    20.2%   $141,000  
 2270570   Mendham Twp.  $749,900    $599,900    $599,900    20.0%   $150,000  
 2390298   Parsippany-Troy Hills  $299,900    $299,900    $240,000    20.0%   $59,900  

Welcome to another edition of Lowball!

Lowball! takes a look at home sales from a different perspective. For those new to Lowball!, a lowball offer is when a buyer offers a significantly lower bid than asking in hopes that the seller accepts the offer. We take a list of home sales from the past month and pick out the sales that have the highest percentage difference between original list price and selling price.

The purpose of Lowball! is to show buyers that the market has changed and buyers now have considerably more leverage than sellers. Just a short time ago, Lowball! offers would have been laughed at and discarded, however, not any more. The fact that so many under-asking offers are being accepted is clear proof that the market is changing.

MLS# Town OLP LP SP % off LP $ off LP
2368012 Oxford Twp. $8,000 $5,000 $4,000 50.0% $4,000
2304950 West Orange Twp. $649,000 $399,900 $350,000 46.1% $299,000
2272503 Alexandria Twp. $899,000 $499,000 $500,000 44.4% $399,000
2306192 Edison Twp. $649,900 $599,000 $362,500 44.2% $287,400
2361990 Ringwood Boro $349,888 $299,888 $200,000 42.8% $149,888
2298084 Montvale Boro $1,899,000 $1,199,000 $1,155,000 39.2% $744,000
2305085 Chatham Twp. $1,699,000 $1,199,000 $1,100,000 35.3% $599,000
2308568 White Twp. $185,000 $159,900 $127,500 31.1% $57,500
2274148 Saddle River Boro $4,750,000 $3,275,000 $3,275,000 31.1% $1,475,000
2274382 Hillsborough Twp. $1,425,000 $1,098,000 $999,000 29.9% $426,000
2293051 Rutherford Boro $899,900 $799,900 $640,000 28.9% $259,900
2372197 Roselle Boro $245,000 $245,000 $175,000 28.6% $70,000
2323597 Washington Twp. $479,900 $349,900 $349,900 27.1% $130,000
2307