Expensive, high interest rate mortgage loans continued to grab a larger share of the market last year, and thousands of homeowners like Paul and Elizabeth Duncan are feeling the squeeze.
The Toms River couple are finding it increasingly hard to make the $3,200 monthly payments on their $327,000 mortgage, which they refinanced last year at a 9 percent interest rate. They are not sure how they are going to make this month’s installment.
“We have more going out than coming in,” Elizabeth Duncan said.
Soon, the Duncans say, they may be forced to sell their new dining room furniture, or take out a cash advance on a credit card in order to make payments and buy some time.
One in four mortgage loans in New Jersey last year were given to subprime borrowers like the Duncans, an Asbury Park Press analysis of new federal mortgage data shows. The loans typically come with interest rates higher than the prevailing market.
The housing and mortgage markets have struggled this year with the effects of those loans, usually granted to borrowers with poor credit or those who had borrowed more than they could afford. Nearly 15 percent of homeowners with subprime loans are late or in default on their payments.
Subprime lending continued at a breakneck pace through last year: 29 percent of all loans nationally, worth $600.2 billion, came with high interest rates, according to the federal data.
That could indicate that many new borrowers will face tough times. The cost of the loans could likely drain family income and force those who are not in trouble yet to begin to default.
The current rise in foreclosures — the highest in 10 years — and late mortgage payments is a ripple effect caused by borrowers who took out loans in 2004 and 2005, experts say. If the 2006 borrowers follow the same pattern, the housing market could see an overwhelming number of defaults in the next couple of years, experts say.
The Press analysis found that in Monmouth and Ocean counties last year:
One in five home loans were granted to subprime borrowers, for a total of $3.1 billion. In 2004, about 1 in 10 loans had gone to subprime borrowers.
The income of subprime borrowers was 5 percent lower than those taking out traditional mortgages, yet the subprime borrowers took out loans that were 10 percent larger. That means subprime borrowers, already facing higher interest rates, will be further strapped to make mortgage payments, especially if their mortgage interest rates adjust upward in the coming years.
More subprime money was lent in 2006 than the prior year. The median subprime loan of $221,000 in 2006 is up from $203,000 in 2005. A median means half borrowed more, half borrowed less.
…
Richard G. Stafford of Capital Home Mortgage in Spring Lake said he believes many borrowers were addicted to shopping.
“They didn’t change their lifestyle,” Stafford said. “The appraisers were generous to them. They just kept refinancing and then maxed their credit cards out again.”
Phyllis Salowe-Kaye, executive director of the consumer advocate group New Jersey Citizen Action, called such comments “blaming the victim.”
She and other advocates fault mortgages sales staff who gave loans to borrowers who never could make the payments long term or made promises that were not kept.
“These people are in business to make money, but they’re in the business to make money on the backs of people,” Salowe-Kaye said.
The Duncans appear to be an example for both arguments.
The couple married in 1999, but with two children each from previous marriages, they soon found that their two-bedroom mobile home was much too small. They bought the three-bedroom colonial in 2004 with $28,000 down and a $211,000 mortgage, land records show.
The Duncans earn $80,000 a year. Paul, 47, works as a dairy manager at a local supermarket. Elizabeth, 43, is a teller at a local bank.
They said they so enjoyed owning the house that they took out a $50,000 home equity loan to build a 450-square-foot family room extension.
They also racked up another $46,420 on five credit cards as they landscaped their front yard, and purchased new televisions, a $5,500 dining room set and a $5,000 pool table.
With bills piling high, a telemarketer called one day and offered a mortgage refinancing to Elizabeth. The woman told her they could refinance all their debt and pay $400 a month less than they were before.